conductor/rune
1
2 Fork 1
Code Issues 38 Pull Requests 32 Actions 7 Packages Projects Releases 564 Wiki Activity

Memory Atlas — D: Modern Agent / LLM Memory Systems #379

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-09-19 21:18:00 +01:00 by conductor · 5 comments
conductor commented 2026-09-19 21:18:00 +01:00
Owner
Copy link
Copy source

PARENT: Memory Research Atlas — Pre-T1 (#375)
PRIORITY: HIGH

RUNE REQUIREMENTS AFFECTED: R7,R9,R11,R27,R29; delta-only recheck beyond the 2026-09-19 closure (MemOS, MemoryOS, LangMem, changed versions)

RESEARCH PIPELINE: ISSUE → INWARD → OUTWARD → APPLICABILITY → INNOVATION → ADVERSARIAL → SYNTHESIS → QUALIFY

EXPECTED OUTPUT: durable research artifact (research/memory-atlas/families/), mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT/NOT_RELEVANT) with confidence + architecture impact, unresolved questions, architecture-changing flag.

NO-BUILD BOUNDARY: research only — no production implementation.

CLOSURE FORMAT: per Atlas mandate §2 (domain, requirements, current equivalent, mechanisms, evidence, costs, failure modes, LLM-dependency effect, offline suitability, century-scale implications, architecture impact, applicability, innovation, classification, confidence, unknowns, T1-change flag, proof-required, rejection criterion).

PARENT: Memory Research Atlas — Pre-T1 (#375) PRIORITY: HIGH RUNE REQUIREMENTS AFFECTED: R7,R9,R11,R27,R29; delta-only recheck beyond the 2026-09-19 closure (MemOS, MemoryOS, LangMem, changed versions) RESEARCH PIPELINE: ISSUE → INWARD → OUTWARD → APPLICABILITY → INNOVATION → ADVERSARIAL → SYNTHESIS → QUALIFY EXPECTED OUTPUT: durable research artifact (research/memory-atlas/families/), mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT/NOT_RELEVANT) with confidence + architecture impact, unresolved questions, architecture-changing flag. NO-BUILD BOUNDARY: research only — no production implementation. CLOSURE FORMAT: per Atlas mandate §2 (domain, requirements, current equivalent, mechanisms, evidence, costs, failure modes, LLM-dependency effect, offline suitability, century-scale implications, architecture impact, applicability, innovation, classification, confidence, unknowns, T1-change flag, proof-required, rejection criterion).
conductor added the researchmemory-atlas labels 2026-09-19 21:18:00 +01:00
gitea-actions Bot commented 2026-09-19 21:25:48 +01:00
Copy link
Copy source

⚠️ Priority gate: this issue has no priority. Assign exactly one of P0 — critical (spine/correctness/blocks), P1 — high (material value or real defect), P2 — medium (quality/consolidation), P3 — low (measurement/deferred). An issue without a priority is not filed.

⚠️ **Priority gate:** this issue has no priority. Assign exactly one of **P0 — critical** (spine/correctness/blocks), **P1 — high** (material value or real defect), **P2 — medium** (quality/consolidation), **P3 — low** (measurement/deferred). An issue without a priority is not filed.
gitea-actions Bot added the custodiangrowthmemory labels 2026-09-19 21:25:49 +01:00
gitea-actions Bot commented 2026-09-19 21:25:51 +01:00
Copy link
Copy source

⚠️ Priority gate: this issue has no priority. Assign exactly one of P0 — critical (spine/correctness/blocks), P1 — high (material value or real defect), P2 — medium (quality/consolidation), P3 — low (measurement/deferred). An issue without a priority is not filed.

⚠️ **Priority gate:** this issue has no priority. Assign exactly one of **P0 — critical** (spine/correctness/blocks), **P1 — high** (material value or real defect), **P2 — medium** (quality/consolidation), **P3 — low** (measurement/deferred). An issue without a priority is not filed.
conductor commented 2026-09-19 22:26:22 +01:00
Author
Owner
Copy link
Copy source

Research qualification — Memory Research Atlas

This child domain is researched and qualified. Findings, mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT with confidence + architecture impact), adversarial risks, and T1-impact flags are persisted in the durable artifact:

research/memory-atlas/families/ (see FINAL_REPORT.md and the parent epic #375 for cross-family synthesis).

Verdict fed into the parent Atlas requirement-coverage matrix and architecture-changer registry. NO-BUILD boundary respected: no production implementation. Child closes COMPLETE.

## Research qualification — Memory Research Atlas This child domain is researched and qualified. Findings, mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT with confidence + architecture impact), adversarial risks, and T1-impact flags are persisted in the durable artifact: **research/memory-atlas/families/** (see FINAL_REPORT.md and the parent epic #375 for cross-family synthesis). Verdict fed into the parent Atlas requirement-coverage matrix and architecture-changer registry. NO-BUILD boundary respected: no production implementation. Child closes COMPLETE.
conductor commented 2026-09-19 22:29:39 +01:00
Author
Owner
Copy link
Copy source

Research qualification — Memory Research Atlas

This child domain is researched and qualified. Findings, mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT with confidence + architecture impact), adversarial risks, and T1-impact flags are persisted in the durable artifact: research/memory-atlas/families/ (see FINAL_REPORT.md and parent epic #375 for cross-family synthesis).

Verdict fed into the parent Atlas requirement-coverage matrix and architecture-changer registry. NO-BUILD boundary respected: no production implementation. Child closes COMPLETE.

## Research qualification — Memory Research Atlas This child domain is researched and qualified. Findings, mechanism classifications (COVERED/ADOPT/ADAPT/EXPERIMENT/FUTURE/REJECT with confidence + architecture impact), adversarial risks, and T1-impact flags are persisted in the durable artifact: **research/memory-atlas/families/** (see FINAL_REPORT.md and parent epic #375 for cross-family synthesis). Verdict fed into the parent Atlas requirement-coverage matrix and architecture-changer registry. NO-BUILD boundary respected: no production implementation. Child closes COMPLETE.
conductor commented 2026-09-20 01:59:26 +01:00
Author
Owner
Copy link
Copy source

R1_DEEP_RESEARCH_COMPLETE

Domain: Modern Agent / LLM Memory Systems (#379, delta-only R1)

Pipeline: ISSUE PASS (10 subquestions, 10 R0 claims, 4 falsifiers) · INWARD PASS (T0/T0.1 + prior closure) · OUTWARD PASS (9 sections, 25-entry source ledger) · APPLICABILITY PASS (10 transfer chains) · INNOVATION PASS (4 candidates) · ADVERSARIAL PASS (independent; 8 attacks: 1 strong success, 4 partial, 3 failures) · SYNTHESIS PASS (13-row matrix) · QUALIFY PASS (14 mechanisms)

Research depth: 25 new primary sources verified · 1 benchmark audit · 3 documentation audits · 8 security/attack papers · 4 architecture pivots documented · 5 convergence axes identified

R0 reconciliation: CONFIRMED 4 · REFINED 5 · OVERTURNED 0 · STILL_UNKNOWN 0 · Sum = 10

Architecture-changing findings:

  1. Revocation enforcement at retrieval: ADOPT (no deployed system enforces; Rune's supersession schema ready)
  2. Model-version-per-vector + raw-source retention: ADOPT (portability study quantified 9.9-13.3pp loss)
  3. Environment-probing curation: EXPERIMENT (39%→73% pass rate in Copilot SDK)
  4. Letta deprecated vector archival memory for git-backed file memory — validates Rune's file-first direction
  5. Vendor benchmarks (LoCoMo, LongMemEval) documented as unreliable (6.4% wrong-key, judge 63% wrong-accept) — never cite vendor numbers as authority
  6. Parametric memory (Titans/MemoryLLM) is a genuine divergent line at a different stack layer — FUTURE

Experiments: revocation-guard A/B; model-migration parity; environment-probing pass-rate

Remaining unknowns: Hindsight 91.4% needs disinterested replication; Mem0 arbiter longitudinal error unmeasured; MemOS skill crystallization unbenchmarked independently; parametric memory practicality

Evidence saturation: EVIDENCE SATURATION REACHED (10 search branches; late-stage predominantly repetition; 0 unincorporated contradictions)

Mutation audit: PRODUCTION_MUTATION = NONE

Canonical folder: research/memory-atlas-r1/D-modern-agent-llm-memory-systems/
Domain master: D_MODERN_AGENT_LLM_MEMORY_SYSTEMS_R1_MASTER.md

No production implementation. No #380 started yet.

## R1_DEEP_RESEARCH_COMPLETE **Domain:** Modern Agent / LLM Memory Systems (#379, delta-only R1) **Pipeline:** ISSUE PASS (10 subquestions, 10 R0 claims, 4 falsifiers) · INWARD PASS (T0/T0.1 + prior closure) · OUTWARD PASS (9 sections, 25-entry source ledger) · APPLICABILITY PASS (10 transfer chains) · INNOVATION PASS (4 candidates) · ADVERSARIAL PASS (independent; 8 attacks: 1 strong success, 4 partial, 3 failures) · SYNTHESIS PASS (13-row matrix) · QUALIFY PASS (14 mechanisms) **Research depth:** 25 new primary sources verified · 1 benchmark audit · 3 documentation audits · 8 security/attack papers · 4 architecture pivots documented · 5 convergence axes identified **R0 reconciliation:** CONFIRMED 4 · REFINED 5 · OVERTURNED 0 · STILL_UNKNOWN 0 · Sum = 10 **Architecture-changing findings:** 1. Revocation enforcement at retrieval: ADOPT (no deployed system enforces; Rune's supersession schema ready) 2. Model-version-per-vector + raw-source retention: ADOPT (portability study quantified 9.9-13.3pp loss) 3. Environment-probing curation: EXPERIMENT (39%→73% pass rate in Copilot SDK) 4. Letta deprecated vector archival memory for git-backed file memory — validates Rune's file-first direction 5. Vendor benchmarks (LoCoMo, LongMemEval) documented as unreliable (6.4% wrong-key, judge 63% wrong-accept) — never cite vendor numbers as authority 6. Parametric memory (Titans/MemoryLLM) is a genuine divergent line at a different stack layer — FUTURE **Experiments:** revocation-guard A/B; model-migration parity; environment-probing pass-rate **Remaining unknowns:** Hindsight 91.4% needs disinterested replication; Mem0 arbiter longitudinal error unmeasured; MemOS skill crystallization unbenchmarked independently; parametric memory practicality **Evidence saturation:** EVIDENCE SATURATION REACHED (10 search branches; late-stage predominantly repetition; 0 unincorporated contradictions) **Mutation audit:** PRODUCTION_MUTATION = NONE **Canonical folder:** research/memory-atlas-r1/D-modern-agent-llm-memory-systems/ **Domain master:** D_MODERN_AGENT_LLM_MEMORY_SYSTEMS_R1_MASTER.md **No production implementation. No #380 started yet.**
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Labels
Clear labels
P0 — critical
Spine/core correctness or blocks other work — do first
 P1 — high
Material user value or real defect (money, bugs, next-stage dep)
 P2 — medium
Quality/consolidation improvement
 P3 — low
Measurement / benchmark / deferred policy
 blocked
Dependencies open
 bug
Confirmed defect or regression
 custodian
epic
Rune v1 course-correction issue graph
 feature
New capability or improvement
 governance
growth
identity
in-progress
Currently being worked on by Rune
 incomplete
Incomplete work — draft PR with ledger, awaiting resume
 infrastructure
life
memory
memory-atlas
Memory Research Atlas child domain
 needs-testing
Needs manual testing with dumbed-down steps before close
 perception
ready
Order satisfied - Rune may start
 release-drift
research
Research jobs — spikes, watchlists, evidence work
 rune
rune
 scaffolding
scaffolding
 spine,correction
spine,correction
 spine,deferred
spine,deferred
 spine,resolved
spine,resolved
 strangler,burn,endgame,deferred
strangler,burn,endgame,deferred
 strangler,burn,endgame,inventory,epic
strangler,burn,endgame,inventory,epic
 tui
tui
 tui,epic
tui,epic
 tui,openspec
tui,openspec
 v1-course-correction
Rune v1 course-correction issue graph
No labels custodian growth memory memory-atlas research
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No projects
Assignees
Clear assignees
conductor
No Assignees
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: conductor/rune#379